2021-2_Pages_12-18

УДК 614.842.615                                          DOI: 10.37657/vniipo.pb.2021.97.68.001

V.P. Molchanov, D.L. Bastrikov, S.A. Makarov,
A.N. Feshchenko, A.V.Tretyakov, I.A. Apanasenko

On the question of the required foam expansion ratio for sublayer extinguishing of oil and oil products fires in vertical steel tanks

Abstract

During the certification tests of high-pressure foam generators for sublayer oil and oil products fire extinguishing in the tanks there is created a conditional back pressure at the generator output, and the foam expansion ratio is measured when this back pressure is no longer present.

In accordance with the standardized methodology the foam expansion ratio is measured in the measuring container by weight.

The derived foam after passing throughout the pipeline is supplied to the measuring container where the foam expansion ratio is measured under the atmospheric pressure.

In practice, during fire extinguishing the flammable liquid exerts a constant excess pressure on the formed foam. The expansion ratio of the foam decreases in proportion to the pressure value of the column.

As a result, the foam expansion ratio can reduce to a value when the Archimedean buoyant force no longer occurs.

In this case, the foam cannot be supplied to the surface of the flammable liquid and the fire cannot be extinguished.

The back pressure created at the tank base depends on the height of the tank wall (level of the liquid fuel filling) and on its density.

Foam rise is possible if the foam density is lower than the fuel density.

Light oil products extinguishing requires greater expansion ratio foam than heavy oil products extinguishing.

At the same time, heavy oil products cause greater back pressure and a decrease in the foam expansion ratio.

Alcohols in the composition of modern high-octane gasolines produce an additional defoaming effect on the foam, which questions the feasibility of using a sublayer fire extinguishing system of modern high-octane gasolines.

The article evaluates a set of parameters that affect the required foam expansion ratio for sublayer extinguishing of oil and oil products fires in tanks and justifies the minimum value of its expansion ratio.

Keywords: fire extinguishing, extinguishing fires in tanks, sublayer foam supply, foam expansion ratio, fuel layer height in the tank

References

1. Sharovatnikov A.F., Molchanov V.P., Voevoda S.S., Sharovarnikov S.A. Tushenie pozharov nefyi i nefteproduktov [Extinguishing of oils and petroleum fires]. Moscow, Kalan Publ., 2002, 448 p. (In Russian).
2. Korolchenko D.A., Sharovarnikov A.F. Factors which reduce fire extinguishing efficiency of sublayer system during suppression of the flame of oil products. Pozharovzryvobezopasnost` – Fire and Explosion Safety, 2016, vol. 25, no. 4, pp. 56–67. (In Russian).
3. GOST R 53290–2009. Tekhnika pozharnaya. Ustanovki pennogo pozharotusheniya. Generatory peny nizkoi kratnosti dlya podsloinogo tusheniya rezervuarov. Obshchie tekhnicheskie trebovaniya. Metody ispytanii. [State Standard Р 53290–2009. Fire engineering. Foam fire-extinguishing installations. Low expansion foam generators for subsurface extinguishing in tanks. General technical requirements]. (In Russian).
4. Sharovarnikov A.F., Sharovarnikov S.A. Penoobrazovateli i peny dlya tusheniya pozharov. Sostav, svoistva, primenenie [Foaming agents and foams for fire extinguishing. Composition, properties, application]. Moscow, Pozhnauka Publ., 2005, 335 p. (In Russian).
5. Feshchenko A.N., Makarov S.A., Molchanov V.P., Tretyakov A.V., Voevoda S.S. Determination of frequency rate of film forming foam for sublayer suppression of the fires of combustible liquids. Pozharovzryvobezopasnost` – Fire and Explosion Safety, 2017, vol. 26, no. 9, pp. 65–73. (In Russian).
6. DIN EN 13565-1-2019. Fixed firefighting systems – Foam systems – Part 1: Requirements and test methods for components; German version EN 13565-1:2019.
7. NFPA 11:2010. Standard for Low-, Medium-, and High-Expansion Foam. 2002 Edition.
8. Makarov S.A., Sautiev M.I., Feshchenko A.N., Tretyakov A.V., Apanasenko I.A. Definition of the main parameters for foam extinguishing of extractively separated alcohol-containing motor fuels. Tekhnologii technosfernoi bezopasnosti – Technology of technosphere safety, 2017, vol. 76, no. 6, pp. 23–30. (In Russian).
9. Feshchenko A.N., Rakhmanin O.K. Opredelenie prigodnosti penoobrazovatelei dlya podsloinogo pozharotusheniya spirtosoderzhashchikh nefteproduktov [Determination of the suitability of foaming agents for sublayer fire extinguishing of alcohol-containing petroleum]. Sbornik materialov VII Mezhdunar. nauch.-prakt. konf. molodykh uchenykh i spetsialistov «Problemy tekhnosfernoi bezopasnosti–2018» [Proceedings of the 7th International Scientific and Practical Conference of Young Scientists and Specialists “Problems of Technosphere Safety-2018”]. Moscow, State Fire Academy of EMERCOM of Russia, 2018, pp. 37–40. (In Russian).
10. Molchanov V.P., Bastrikov D.L., Voevoda S.S, Sharovarnikov A.F. Extinguishing of the flame of polar combustible liquids. Pozharovzryvobezopasnost` – Fire and Explosion Safety, 2012, vol. 21, no. 6, pp. 69–73. (In Russian).
11. Molchanov V.P., Voevoda S.S, Makarov C.A., Bastrikov D.L., Krutov M.A. Extinction of motor fuel fires of European standard by law expansion foam. Pozharovzryvobezopasnost` – Fire and Explosion Safety, 2011, vol. 20, no. 4, pp. 49–53. (In Russian).

Received February 3, 2021

Аuthors:

Viktor P. Molchanov – Doctor of Technical Sciences, Deputy General Director for Science;

Denis L. Bastrikov – Candidate of Technical Sciences, Director of the Department of Fire and Industrial Safety of the Hazardous Production Facilities. E-mail: dlbastrikov@mail.ru

(International Fire Center LLC). Moscow, Russia;

Sergey A. Makarov – Candidate of Technical Sciences, Associate Professor;

Alexander N. Feshchenko – Senior Lecturer

(State Fire Academy, EMERCOM of Russia), Moscow, Russia;

Alexey V. Tretyakov – Director General (LLC «EGIDA PTV»). Moscow, Russia;

Igor A. Apanasenko – Post-graduate student (State Fire Academy, EMERCOM of Russia), Moscow, Russia.